Saturday, October 18, 2025

Faulty Perception


I went to the city on Thursday to see a photographic exhibit with Stan.  Penn Station is on 32nd Street and the gallery is on 18th Street and a few blocks west.  So I decided to walk to the gallery instead of taking a subway.   I was walking down Eighth avenue, with my camera at the ready.  I saw this man on his phone and was taken with his dark clothing and all the storefronts were dark as well.  I walked past him, and then thought, "What are you, an idiot?  Go back and shoot that!"  So after I passed him I turned around and headed back up the avenue and when I got about 40 feet past him, I stopped, turned around and made about 5 or 6 shots of the scene.  I liked that the entire photograph would be dark because of the man's chothing and the storefronts.  They call this a "low key" photograph because it is mainly made up of just the darker tones.  So I think it is a bit interesting, but I don't know.  But, imagine my surprise when I came home and started editing this image...


I was stunned!  Yes, the storefront was dark but it was lit by bright sunlight!  And I never noticed that!  I was in shock that my photograph was not all "low key."  So there are ways to fix this.  In the days of film, when making a print you can "burn in" brighter areas to darken them down.  So that's what I did with this photograph, and I darkened all the sunlit areas.  And I like my final result but I am still in shock that I did not SEE this when I took the picture.  Thought you would find this explanation interesting.



 

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

It is interesting how the sun was shining on that one area, but I definitely like the low-key photo better for the darker lighting. Trace

Betsey said...

Can’t believe the difference between the two photos. I actually like the first darker photo better because of the feeling it evokes.

ken schwarz said...

The top shot is the winner, This urban photo is all about the guy leaning against a dark city building with his cell phone late in the day. The building's reflective light in the lower version detracts from the mood, in my opinion.

Ken Spencer said...

Thank you all for your nice comments! And your sensibilities. You all chose the "correct" photograph, in my opinion!