The Collector

This is another case of following another walker down on the beach, from overhead.  I photographed this woman first, then the dog walker.  So there are two different photographs and I am trying to figure out which is best.  I think it is the one above.  I like that she is pretty much in silhouette, with no details visible.  I chose one where she is leaning a bit forward.

I took this one before the one above and we can see details in the woman and her clothing.  So I can't decide if seeing the way she is dressed matters.  She is apparently collecting "something" but she was asked by someone down on the beach what she was looking for with her little white net on the end of a stick, and she did not seem to give an answer. She does have a long white plastic bag on her front to put whatever she was looking for, into.  This second photograph has more detail, including her brightly decorated leggings, but I don't think this photograph is as effective as an interesting image.  What do you all think?  Would you choose the first photograph, or the second?  Thank you in advance for you choices.  Oh, please click on each image to see more detail before voting.  Thanks!